CAPF AC 2023 Q1: General Mental Ability – Logical Reasoning & Puzzles
Pointing towards a photograph Mr. Ajit said, “She is my father's wife's son's only sister.” What is the relation of the person in the photograph with Mr. Ajit?
- (a) Daughter
- (b) Mother's sister
- (c) Cousin
- (d) Sister
Answer: (d) Sister
Explanation
Blood relation puzzle
Given: pointing towards a photograph Mr. Ajit said, She is my father's wife's son's only sister; find her relation with Mr. Ajit.
How to think: read the chain one link at a time, starting from Ajit.
| Link in the chain | Who that is |
|---|---|
| My father's wife | Ajit's mother |
| Her son | Ajit himself (or his brother) |
| That son's only sister | Ajit's sister |
So the woman in the photograph is Ajit's sister.
Answer: (d) Sister.
Why each option is right or wrong
- (a) Incorrect. A daughter would be one generation below Ajit; the chain stays in his own generation.
- (b) Incorrect. Mother's sister would need the words mother's sister, not mother's son's sister.
- (c) Incorrect. A cousin is the child of an uncle or aunt, not of Ajit's own mother.
- (d) CORRECT. Father's wife is the mother, her son is Ajit, and his only sister is Ajit's sister.
Key point
Blood relations: resolve the chain step by step from the speaker. Father's wife = mother. Mother's son = self or brother. Brother's sister = own sister. The word only removes any doubt about which sister.
Remember
Father's wife's son's sister = my sister.
Common mistakes
- Reading the chain from the end instead of starting with the speaker.
- Taking father's wife's son as a half-brother and making the puzzle harder than it is.
- Jumping a generation and answering daughter or aunt.
Exam tip
Educated guess: count the generations. Father goes up one, son comes down one, sister stays level. Net change is zero, so she is in Ajit's own generation: a sister.
Sources
- R. S. Aggarwal, A Modern Approach to Verbal and Non-Verbal Reasoning — Blood Relations
- NCERT Class VI Mathematics — Knowing Our Numbers and logical reasoning exercises